Republicans Make Another Major Move On IVF

Photo by freestocks on Unsplash

( – On a recent Wednesday, an attempt by Senate Republicans to pass a bill safeguarding the federal rights to in vitro fertilization (IVF) was halted. The initiative, championed by Sen. Tammy Duckworth (D-IL), was thwarted when Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS) objected. This objection was critical because the bill’s passage required unanimous consent, meaning any single senator’s dissent could derail the process.

Hyde-Smith criticized the bill as overly broad and laden with contentious provisions, asserting it would enable practices such as human cloning, commercial surrogacy without age or parental restrictions, the creation of genetically altered babies, and the lifting of the ban on creating embryos with three genetic parents. In contrast, Duckworth refuted these claims, emphasizing that the bill merely aimed to guarantee individuals the legal right to seek assisted reproductive technologies without mandating their use, provision, or insurance coverage.

Despite some Republicans voicing their support for IVF, they expressed reluctance to impose federal regulations over what they view as a state-governed issue, questioning the necessity of federal safeguards for IVF access.

Duckworth criticized her colleagues for their lack of action beyond mere expressions of support for women’s rights, particularly in light of the Alabama Supreme Court’s decision that classified frozen embryos as children. This ruling led to the suspension of IVF services by several Alabama clinics, due to standard practices involving the disposal of nonviable or surplus embryos.

The Democrats are pointing fingers at the Republican Party for the implications of the Alabama decision, aiming to leverage it against former President Trump in his bid for the GOP nomination. Duckworth announced her intention to request a formal roll call vote from Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), despite anticipating it could consume weeks of Senate floor time. This move seeks to document Republican positions on the matter officially, amidst their public endorsements of IVF amidst the controversy.

Copyright 2024,