Lindsay Clancy’s Lawyer Turns To Trump With Desperate Plea

Lindsay Clancy’s lawyer went on national television and asked President Trump for a pardon after a state-court mistrial.

Story Snapshot

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington made a direct, on-air pardon plea to President Trump.
The Massachusetts murder case ended in a mistrial after a deadlocked jury.
Presidential pardons cover federal crimes, not state charges like this case.
The defense is pressing a public argument while prosecutors weigh next steps.

A Televised Plea That Jumped Past the Courthouse

Defense attorney Kevin Reddington used a Good Morning America interview to speak straight to President Trump. He asked the President to “consider a pardon” for Lindsay Clancy days after a judge declared a mistrial in her Massachusetts murder case. The moment was striking because it bypassed the usual legal channels and aimed at the most powerful clemency tool in America. The appeal also leaned on Clancy’s hardships and the hung jury, a mix designed to stir public empathy and political attention.

Lindsay Clancy attorney Kevin Reddington making an appeal to Trump: "Mr. President, I would hope that you would consider, this young lady, the type of person she is, what she's been through, and consider a pardon." pic.twitter.com/dk2zO03XHv

— Townhall.com (@townhallcom) September 8, 2026

The courtroom drama had already peaked. The judge declared the jury deadlocked and entered a mistrial, resetting the legal board to zero for both sides. A mistrial means no verdict and no final judgment. The case can be tried again. Prosecutors can refile or seek a new trial. The defense can pursue deals. No one won, and no one got cleared. That gray zone often fuels media fights and high-stakes messaging wars over what should happen next.

What a Pardon Can Do, and What It Cannot

The United States Constitution lets presidents forgive federal crimes. It does not let them forgive state crimes. That boundary is not a guess; it is clear in Justice Department guidance and long-standing legal analysis. Clancy’s charges come from a Massachusetts court under state law, not from a federal court. A White House pardon would not reach this case. If her team seeks clemency, the lawful path runs through Massachusetts, likely the governor or a state clemency board.

These limits do more than shut a door. They show why some televised pardon asks are really public pressure campaigns. Lawyers sometimes aim at Washington to shape narratives, rally supporters, and nudge local actors. That tactic can work in politics but cannot bend the text of the Constitution. American conservatives value federalism for exactly this reason: states run their own criminal justice, and Washington stays in its lane. That line keeps power closer to communities and juries.

The Mistrial’s Meaning and the Road Ahead

A hung jury means the panel could not agree. The judge ends the trial, and the case remains unresolved. The charges do not vanish. Prosecutors can try again, often after reviewing what evidence landed and what missed. Defense teams use the pause to reassess witnesses, experts, and strategy. Some cases flip at this stage into plea talks. Others head straight to a new jury. This is the grind of criminal law: second looks, fewer surprises, and sharper arguments the next time.

Lawyer asks Trump to pardon Lindsay Clancy after deadlocked jury

Lindsay Clancy’s attorney, Kevin Reddington, has appealed to President Donald Trump to consider a pardon for his client following a mistrial in her murder trial last week.

ABC News reports that Reddington made the… pic.twitter.com/2fg44tnFLQ

— Rifnote (@viarifnote) September 8, 2026

Public attention will stay high because the stakes are severe and the facts are tragic. Reddington argued that Clancy’s story and struggles deserve mercy and a broader view. Critics point to the victims and want accountability to come first. Both instincts run hot after a mistrial, when no verdict gives either side closure. The next formal move belongs to the local district attorney, not the Oval Office. Expect decisions on retrial timing, charge posture, and possible negotiations soon.